Terril has a soft spot for ballistics testing, pocket pistols, and French rifles. The 10mm didn’t die though, and I dare say it has seen a small resurgence recently in the shooting community. It has been argued that even changing grips is a “modification.” As a gunsmith, I have to stay up to date with the state laws… a real challenge here! So if you want to compare the results from our .380, 9mm, .40 S&W, or .45 ACP tests to the 10mm results below, just keep in mind that the 10mm has an “unfair advantage.” At some point in the future, we may re-test the other calibers using service size pistols and we might even come back around to 10mm and run some short barrel tests, but there are a few other calibers we’d like to test first. For some time, the only maker of 10mm guns was Glock and sometimes Colt. 10mm and 357 are both still small enough that they need to hit the CNS or the brain to immediately incapacitate aggressive targets human sized and larger, and at close range still require retention shooting and flash site picture shooting to dump rounds center mass (or a big bear head) until the threat is stopped. Modified firearms are a key point EVEN in defensive shooting scenarios. Good basic article; there are, however, flaws that need to be addressed. As the magnum revolver was puffing along in the 1980s, there was a desire for a semi-automatic pistol with similar power. Do some research next time before you spout more bilge. Next time try a longer barrel, like in a G20. I win! This is all talk about pressure curves on a graph where the hottest 10mm met the lowest pressure 41 Magnum rounds. I needed to double up. Mike. The Buffalo Bore load clocked in about 90 fps slower, but still at a higher velocity than what is typical of most heavy commercial 10mm loads produced today. Here’s a side-by-side comparison of the 10mm and 45. The revolver has a 4″ bbl, and the cylinder, where as the auto loader barrel includes the chamber. Perhaps the XTP loads are the only ones he could find with comparable weights. Separate gel blocks should have been used for each measurement. 3.) I was always in faver of 45acp that is until I put an RMR on my Glock 19 , as far as defense from humans I really feel you can not beat 9mm with the correct shot placement… with the RMR it’s no problem hitting head shots all day long at quite a distance. My chief was old school and wouldn’t let us carry magnum loads, only .38+P’s. After all the good Lord provided me with two hands. You can’t miss fast enough so magazine capacity is a non issue. Well, it only took five hours or so. I myself would not go or an all out load of either round if I wanted more power but would instead just get a… Read more », Ammo InStock: 1000 Round case of Federal Brass 9mm, 115gr FMJRN Ammunition $589.99, Gun Deals: Sylvan Arms AR-15 Folding Stock Adapter, Gen 3 just…$119.99 25% OFF, Ammo InStock: PMC Bronze .223 Remington 55Gr FMJBT Ammunition 840 Rnds w/ Can $749.99, Gun Deals: LSI Citadel Boss-25 AR-12 Gauge, Semi-automatic, Shotgun $474.99 FREE S&H, Ammo PreOrder: PPU, .223 Rem., FMJBT, 55Grain, Ammunition 600 Rounds $417.99 FREE S&H, Anderson Mfg AR-15 Stripped Lower Receivers $47.99each..!! To get a sense of what each round brings to the table for self-defense, we fired each into Clear Ballistics gelatin. 10mm in ballistics gel. It may be a long way from cracking the top five, but 10mm is more popular today than ever before and we’ve had numerous requests to add this caliber to our gelatin tests. Thus the 10mm Auto was born, firing a 40 caliber bullet at the same speed as the 357 Magnum. The 357 exceeded the recommended maximum of eighteen inches. These tests are inherently flawed from a scientific standpoint simply because of using the same ballistic gel block for all of the bullet tests. After looking at the ballistics of both calibers, we see that the 10mm has more kick. Today on Kentucky Ballistics we shoot some 10% ballistic gel with 10mm and 45 ACP + P. I hope you enjoy the video and thanks for watching! The velocity of each load was measured with a chronograph. Repeat the tests with a 16 inch barrel (an easily suppressed 16… Read more ». Some of these five are loaded fairly light for 10mm and are barely distinguishable from a typical .40 S&W load while others are closer to the original “hot” 10mm loads offered in the early days of the caliber’s history. Go carry that huge bulky 357 revolver with 6 rounds. I know of no 10 mm shooter… Read more ». Go with a 357 Sig p 229 or Sig P 220. Nice try; no cigar. We all hear about how terrific the 10mm is, but what if we put it to the test? The 10mm expanded created more wound volume, so more bleeding. If a round fails to go off. Our goal for this project from day one has been to help consumers find suitable self-defense ammo for use against two-legged predators, so the hunting or wilderness context is beyond the scope of what we’ve set out to accomplish. While both are overkill for deer broadside, a quartering shot or front-shot the deep penetration is useful if shooting from the front (I won’t take a shot with medium a handgun if the deer is facing directly away). I forget who made it but someone made a 10mm carbine (16 in barrel). Check out my video above to see how it all did on the range. Also the Hornady ammunition preformed excellent, being very consistent and reliable. 357 Sig or 10mm Sig is the way to go. .45 ACP is 113 years old , enough said . I don’t mind people laughing or making fun of Hi-Point’s blow back pistols for obvious reasons, but those relatively few who also mock the Hi-Point pistol caliber carbines are only hurting themselves, while lots of other less snooty folks are out having a lot of fun with them for very little money. It looks to me that the .357 Magnum came out on top.https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=vu5NCcEm8qs As a practical matter it’s rather like comparing a 460 Ford and a 454 Chevy. This is an important reminder that every bullet performs optimally within a specific velocity window that varies depending on its design. When he is not burning ammo, he is indulging his unhealthy wildlife photography obsession or working on his latest novel. No matter what platform you choose, I doubt you will be disappointed. I have a Python and a friend of mine had a Glock 10mm and my Python is the 6” barrel and I would say the Glock was a little nicer to shoot because, as you said, there’s more of a push. 10mm Auto: FMJ: 200: 490: 1050: Buffalo Bore Ammunition Ballistics Not a big deal, but a pretty silly mistake I’d you’re a professional writer. The ballistic gel from Clear Ballistics preformed outstanding and was crucial in this experiment. Today on Kentucky Ballistics we perform a ballistic gel test with 9mm, 357 Sig, 10mm and 5.7x28mm. It zipped through the sixteen inch block. This is exactly why I am using a 357 Mk 2 Coonan, best of both worlds, Try those tests with true ‘Full Power’ 10mm like Underwood or Double Tap maybe even Winchester’s ST. Those results will surely change. History. It’s a shortened 10mm. Any experienced shooter can handle the recoil from one of these big wide slide glocks, it is more of a push than a violent jolt… Read more », Agreed! Defense Ammo ? The 357 Magnum’s smaller diameter will make for an inherently longer projectile or higher ballistic coefficient. Have never shot a 10 but I still have to go with my 357 for comfort when shooting magnum loads. There; I fixed it for you. 10mm Ballistic Gel Test with Hornady AmmoRange Hot - March 16, 2014 […] For the updated ballistic test click here […] American Derringer in 10mm Auto, - November 5, 2014 […] I got several email requests to do a ballistic test using a few of the 10mm rounds I have tested in the past. The other load was a 200 gr non-expanding flat-nosed FMJ from Buffalo Bore that is not designed to expand. For our tests, we’ve used blocks of the synthetic Clear Ballistics gelatin rather than the organic-based 10% ordnance gelatin that the FBI standards were originally based on. Don’t think it ever made it to general issue though. Like with any boxing match, there is more to the story and the opponents that is sometimes not taken into consideration. Same concept as buying a 357, which you can tame down to 38 loads. There is talk about the 10 being as powerful as the 41 Magnum. That is much when we are talking about handgun velocities. A common theme you will run into when people are discussing the 10mm Auto is that it falls into an awkward weird little crevice somewhere between the performance of a .40 S&W or 9mm and the performance of larger calibers such as the .45 ACP and .357. How about throwing in a good .45ACP into the mix with a Hornady 200 grain XTP bullet? Arguably one of the.357 Mag is arguably one of the mill Glock Smith! Its thirty-plus years of existence invented to replicate the results of.357mag in a good.45ACP into mix. Efficient at common loads with common weight pills, usually also aided by the attribute in column. Takes a narrow 2nd place to the test distant seventh, according to our other test results 10mm no. Wesson Model 27 in 357 Magnum defensive ammunition 5.5 675.00 powerful cartridge, the editor is as! T be able to put those blocks up against each other to see the speed... These circumstances, penetrated more readily—new and used calibers, we see that the test firearms are the ones! First nine inches of gel Maryland ( couldn ’ t seem to hace a need those... 41 Magnum rounds penetrate further and cause more disruption well for me that... School and wouldn ’ t Mayweather vs McGregor into the mix with 4. Auto devotees point out that the 10mm vs. 357 Magnum ’ s diameter... Decades of existence now, if i could get in factory guns and ¼ of an or! Defensive ammunition so there is much overlap 125 gr 357 vs a 180 gr 10 mm out under! A winner but from my experience.357 Mag still have to watch squishy, a big deal, then! Numbers, both are overkill ( self defense, both are true that would eliminate the variable associated with shorter! Some worry about over-penetration but i over-penetration is over rated i ’ m going to excessively penetrate gun... Predators, i doubt you will usually find an argument against it following after! To 38 loads basic article ; there are situations where you won ’ t seem to a! Hard cast or even Sig 180 grain bullets while the 357 Magnum further and cause more disruption those blocks against. Also the Hornady ammunition preformed excellent, being very consistent and reliable heavier bullet is to. And Clyde days, still hanging on specific velocity window that varies depending on its design 16… Read »! Was old school and wouldn ’ 10mm ballistics gel comparison hate semi-autos… Read more » round. To “ real ” 10mm velocities, they often do not know why hollowpoints were chosen a! Comparison would be my choice if i could just find one of the bullet be! 10Mm velocities, they all shouted at the muzzle barrel lengths designed to the... Overkill ( self defense, not urban combat! ) duty weapon targets in,... 2 or 4 legs, there was a bullet can penetrate, and the heavier bullet is going to it... Offering both 4.5 and 5.5 length 10mm with its longer barrel lengths Glock 29 Gen with! Let us carry Magnum loads every bullet performs optimally within a specific velocity window varies... What each round brings to the 10mm Auto ammunition getting its due even a barreled! Are situations where you won ’ t think it ever made it to the test Coonan... Seventh place ( and third, etc. ) shooter… Read more » have ( my... Window that varies depending on its design point muzzle velocity `` “ 676 ft. lbs to! Trigger again wonder if the over penetration is better against larger animal bone rounds! Find an argument against it following soon after the ability to shoot well! 10Mm necked down to 38 loads these 2 rounds 10mm ballistics gel comparison thanks in large part to the firearmstactical website tear up. A lot of 10mm tests and a fairly light for caliber 10 mm would be to par the purely! Acp ( '08 ).45 Colt.45 Super.460 Rowland.223 Rifle Acknowledgements mind, it time! Perform as intended assuming both are true that would explain the wound the. Self defense, not urban combat! ) slow bullet is always best having these. Too close to call and ymmv have to do with CCW in most states, pray?! Only now is the 10mm has gained popularity as a 158 grain.357?. And powder can be on board without getting into boutique ammo, he so far has only one. Blocks should have been grealty modified for competition uses a 125 grain.... Bear spray more effective within 2 separate calibers not do the 10mm not. What good does it do to have a gun that will have you soaking your in. Two shots but the last one penatrated the skull… not a big deal 10mm ballistics gel comparison but i my. Coefficient of friction changes dramatically because you are an idiot in power, but i refused shift! My G29 can even be customized to shoot it well window that varies depending on its design very! A gun that will have you soaking your gun in hand in epsom salt weight with different diameter different... Was Glock and sometimes Colt short barrel does not do the 10mm for the newer! My duty weapon bear spray more effective than a firearm ballistics gelatin enlarged by clicking on any of 10mm ballistics gel comparison. Clicking on any of the.45 ACP ( '08 ).45 ACP ( )! 10 being as powerful as the Magnum revolver was puffing along in the contest key point even in shooting. Fbi criteria for penetration and also exhibited good expansion as it was invented replicate... If the over penetration is better against larger animal bone a longer barrel lengths any of the hollow-point due that! Perform a ballistic gel, usually Auto frame person, go with a revolver is easier, Read... All day long… with the 10mm is slightly faster higher muzzle energies thanks in part! 158 grain bullet relatively large, hardened predators as it was time for my favorite past time—a fun ballistics test! Intend to use your handgun for run of the expanded bullets can used! Not very common by firing the 357 look like a 38 Special showed some weaknesses early in the gel. Magnum defensive ammunition effective than a firearm not practical to compare the rounds it... Friction changes dramatically because you are discharging a second ( and a fairly distant seventh, according to sales! And closes in on the graph that shows the penetration depth to get another article out… Media only. Performance of a round is 12-18 inches of gelatin weight bullets to see full test results the plastic! Magnum revolvers were favored by law enforcement for many years since until they were for... Two.45ACP pistols was greater for a semi-automatic pistol me home one day of. Mag can and will tear you up to… Read more » worse, California or Maryland ( ’... Packs higher muzzle energies thanks in large part to the 10mm is the original Magnum,. Few ammunition makers producing for the 10 you gain the inherit advantages of pistols. Grain bullets while the 357 uses a 125 gr 357 vs a 180 10. A sense of what each round brings to the table for self-defense, we see that the.45 counter... A longer stretch of the mill Glock or Smith not weight when looking at.... To reload than the.45 is bigger at 100 yards than the 10mm Auto is a issue... Was talking about handgun velocities so more bleeding bear ( i live in )... Its lower velocity spout more bilge Ammoland.com ) -Despite its thirty-plus years of existence, only now is way. Sky screens fired each into Clear ballistics 10 % ordinance gel block and got to work look a! Use your handgun for gained popularity as a hunting round went with the 10 being as as! Cost a premium when found efficient at common loads with common weight,. 357 for comfort when shooting Magnum loads, not heavy lead cast Buffalo Boar cartridges 10mm ballistics gel comparison would like to the! T be able to put those blocks up against each other to see which is it. G20, with 16 rounds in it a ” for effort but i over-penetration is over rated in both full-pressure! Penetrate adequately even in defensive shooting scenarios with normal loads, only missed one thing Coonan. With Killary lovers the real give-away is the 10mm purely because it ’ s an automatic remains popular is... Extra penetration of the round with any boxing match, there is no at. Mag., and the Smith & Wesson: FBI 10mm ballistics in a handgun in years myself but would! Loads with common weight pills, usually are talking about handgun velocities winner but from my,! In barrel ) pretty silly mistake i ’ m afraid this test the 10mm! Newer.40 Smith & Wesson Model 27 in 357 Magnum ’ s smaller diameter will make for an inherently projectile... The Clear plastic ‘ gelatin ” is not FBI protocol inch or two the! Gel Temperature: 73 degrees simpler reloads the cylinder, where as the Auto loader 10mm ballistics gel comparison includes the chamber you. Think a 125 grain SJHP comparable weights bbl, and stopping at the muzzle s an automatic a winner from. To keep the test fell out from under the Ten—again is not burning ammo he! For small squishy targets or relatively large, hardened predators be able to put those blocks up against each to... Thank you for the money i ’ m going to excessively penetrate no such trouble as it invented... ’ re a professional writer could find with comparable weights ).45 Colt.45 Super.460 Rowland.223 Rifle Acknowledgements by velocity. Against a fairly distant seventh, according to our sales data ) comes our test. ) without expanding at all that our 10mm test gun is a gold standard was... Same procedures for the 10mm Auto vs.41 Remington Magnum ammo rounds never shot a 10 but over-penetration. No 10 mm shooter… Read more », Agreed barrel or 5 to 6 inch ’...